‘Not To My Knowledge’ Ignites Firestorm

Reporters and photographers gathered outside a neoclassical courthouse
Photo: Shutterstock

Rep. Ilhan Omar’s own words — “Not to my knowledge” — have reignited a seven-year-old marriage controversy just as federal officials threaten a new investigation and possible deportation proceedings.

Quick Take

  • Omar answered “Not to my knowledge” when asked on live television if she’s related to her ex-husband, Ahmed Nur Said Elmi.
  • Public records confirm Omar legally married Elmi in 2009, but the marriage wasn’t dissolved until 2017.
  • A Star Tribune records review could not confirm or rule out the claim that Elmi is Omar’s brother.
  • A top Department of Homeland Security official recently revived the allegation and raised the possibility of deportation if fraud is found.
  • Omar denies the claim outright, calling it absurd and tracing its origin to a Somali political blog.

A Decade-Old Marriage Still Raises Questions

Hennepin County records show Omar married Ahmed Nur Said Elmi on February 12, 2009. The marriage wasn’t legally dissolved until December 4, 2017, according to both The Associated Press and the Star Tribune. During part of that time, Omar and Ahmed Hirsi, the man she describes as her husband, filed joint tax returns in 2014 and 2015 — while her marriage to Elmi remained legally active.

Her Answer Reopens an Old Debate

During an October interview on MS NOW with host Chris Hayes, Omar was asked whether she had any family connection to Elmi. She replied, “Not to my knowledge.” A detailed review of the full exchange found that answer addressed a follow-up question about any relation to Elmi, not a separate question about whether she had married her own brother.

Omar has said for years that the sibling claim is false. She has called it “absurd and offensive” and said she has no brother by that name. She has traced the allegation’s origin to a Somali-language blog that she says was later picked up and spread by conservative activists in Minneapolis.

What Public Records Do and Don’t Show

The Star Tribune conducted an extensive review of marriage and divorce filings, business licenses, university records, and public databases tied to Omar and Elmi. The paper stated plainly that it “could neither conclusively confirm nor rebut” the allegation that Elmi was Omar’s sibling. That finding means the core claim behind the controversy remains publicly unresolved, even after years of scrutiny from journalists, campaign-finance regulators, and political opponents.

A Minnesota Campaign Finance and Public Disclosure Board investigation separately found that Omar’s campaign spent money on legal services tied to the tax filing issue, not on the marriage itself. That finding documents an irregular paper trail around Omar’s finances, but it does not establish that Elmi was her relative or that the 2009 marriage was used to gain immigration benefits.

Government Scrutiny Returns

A Department of Homeland Security official recently revived the sibling allegation publicly, saying deportation could follow if an investigation turns up fraud. That statement marks a shift from years of the claim circulating mainly among commentators and advocacy websites, including one site hosting a legal brief alleging federal and state crimes by Omar — a document whose sourcing and authentication have not been independently verified.

No criminal charge, court ruling, or completed federal investigation has established that Elmi was Omar’s brother or that the marriage was fraudulent. The gap between a documented marital and tax timeline, which is real, and an unproven kinship claim, which is not, is where this story has lived for nearly a decade. Each side treats that gap differently, which is exactly why it keeps resurfacing in Washington.

Sources:

startribune.com, motherjones.com, btimesonline.com, yahoo.com, primetimer.com

© truthandliberty.com 2026. All rights reserved.