How Resuming Loan Payments Might Affect Borrowers’ Financial Stability

US Department of Education website student loans grants

Federal student loan delinquencies have exploded from less than 1% to 8% as the government resumes collection activities after a 43-month payment pause, plunging millions of Americans into financial turmoil.

Quick Takes

  • Student loan delinquency rates surged to 8% in Q1 2025, up from 0.8% a year earlier, marking the highest level in five years
  • The Education Department has reinstated aggressive collection tactics including wage garnishment, tax return seizures, and Social Security benefit garnishments
  • Seven Southern states have delinquency rates exceeding 30%, with Mississippi, Alabama, and West Virginia among the hardest hit
  • Borrowers aged 40 and older show higher delinquency rates than younger borrowers, contradicting common assumptions about student debt
  • Late-paying borrowers have seen credit scores plummet by up to 171 points, with long-term financial consequences

Millions Face Delinquency After Federal Collection Efforts Resume

American borrowers are facing severe financial consequences as student loan delinquencies have surged after the end of pandemic-era protections. Nearly 8% of total student debt was reported as 90 days past due in the first quarter of 2025, compared to less than 1% a year earlier, according to data from the Federal Reserve Bank of New York. This dramatic spike represents approximately six million borrowers who are now past due or in default, accounting for over 10% of all student loan balances. The surge follows the expiration of a 43-month pause on federal student loan payments implemented during the pandemic.

“Transition rates into serious delinquency have leveled off for credit card and auto loans over the past year, however, the first batch of past due student loans were reported in the first quarter of 2025, resulting in a large jump in seriously delinquent borrowers.” stated Daniel Mangrum

The Education Department restarted aggressive collection efforts on defaulted student loans on May 5, employing tactics that include garnishment of wages, seizure of tax returns, and withholding Social Security payments. These measures will initially affect 195,000 borrowers, with wage garnishment notices to follow for 5.3 million defaulted borrowers in coming months. This enforcement follows the Supreme Court’s 2023 decision to block President Biden’s mass student loan forgiveness initiative, forcing the administration to shift focus from blanket loan cancellation to restoring repayment discipline.

Southern States and Older Borrowers Hit Hardest

The resumption of required payments has not affected all Americans equally. Seven states now have delinquency rates higher than 30%, forming a concerning cluster in the Southern region: Mississippi, Alabama, West Virginia, Kentucky, Oklahoma, Arkansas, and Louisiana. This regional concentration suggests underlying economic vulnerabilities that may be exacerbating borrowers’ ability to manage their student loan obligations. The geographic disparity highlights how student loan stress is not uniformly distributed across the country but concentrated in regions already facing economic challenges.

“The ramifications of student loan delinquency are severe”

Contrary to popular perception that student loan struggles primarily affect younger Americans, the data reveals borrowers aged 40 and older actually have higher delinquency rates than those under 40. The highest rates are among those aged 40-49, suggesting a significant portion of student debt belongs to parents who borrowed for their children’s education or individuals who pursued higher education later in life. These findings challenge conventional narratives about student debt being primarily a younger generation’s burden and point to a more complex financial reality for middle-aged Americans.

Credit Scores Plummet as Household Debt Reaches Record Levels

The resumption of delinquency reporting has triggered substantial damage to borrowers’ credit scores. Analysis shows that consumers facing default have seen their credit scores fall by an average of 63 points, with super prime borrowers experiencing even more dramatic drops of up to 175 points. This credit score deterioration has far-reaching implications, affecting borrowers’ ability to secure housing, employment, and access to affordable credit for years to come, creating a potential domino effect of financial hardship beyond just student loan repayment.

“The impact that it showed to these people’s credit scores is pretty staggering, that is something that is going to make things harder for people for a long time. There is very little in life that is more expensive than having crummy credit.” expressed Matt Schulz

These developments come as Americans contend with record levels of household debt across all categories. Total household debt rose by $167 billion to approximately $18.2 trillion from January through March 2025. Mortgage balances increased by $199 billion during this period, though auto loans and credit card debt showed modest decreases of $13 billion and $29 billion respectively. The overall household debt delinquency rate has risen to 4.3%, with student loans being the primary driver while other debt categories have remained relatively stable, suggesting the student loan crisis represents a unique pressure point in Americans’ financial health.

Sources:

  1. NY Fed: Student loan borrowing trouble surged in first quarter
  2. Student Loans Drive US Delinquency Rate to Highest Since 2020
  3. As student loan default rate spikes, some borrowers face ‘grave consequences,’ New York Fed says

RELATED ARTICLESMORE FROM AUTHOR